3

There's a tag.

Should it exist? Is it being well used?

Asking fundamental “beginner” questions says that the site shouldn't be 'seeded' artificially with beginner questions; but what about 'beginner' questions which appear naturally, which are asked by beginners?

I suggest that tags are to help people find things. Interested and knowledgeable people could perhaps 'curate' the collection of 'beginner' questions:

  • Add the 'beginner' tag to questions that are especially interesting to beginners
  • Remove the 'beginner' tag from questions that are not especially interesting to beginners

Perhaps the beginner tag shouldn't exist at all (see The Death of Meta Tags) -- although for this subject (i.e. for Buddhism, although not for StackOverflow which deals with software development problems) the beginner tag is appropriate, IMHO.

The comments to this question suggest that collecting/tagging 'beginner' questions might be helpful.

2

I am (very) new to the site, but here is my opinion. I believe the subject matter (existing tag) and summary of each question are adequate to allow the user to filter through what they want to read or don't. As an analogy, if I went into a bookstore and walked to a section that interested me, I wouldn't normally find a sub-section called "Beginners". I would browse the titles and pick out what struck me.

For beginner's knowledge I would think that users would do some historical or scriptural study to gain a basic level of knowledge.

Hope offering my opinion helps. I'm sure others can make a good argument for the Beginner tags. BTW, I am truly impressed by what I see on the site so far.

0

Yes it should. I have not used it but some people may like to use it. If it helps people feel welcome then why not.

  • "Why not": because it's difficult to decide how to use it well. Should it be used for every topic? If not, which topics should and shouldn't it be used for? A potential problem is that, if the tag is misleading (by saying "This is a beginner topic; and, other topics which don't have this tag are not beginner topics") then it's harmful, or doing more harm than good. – ChrisW Jan 25 '15 at 20:21
  • Yes. Only for a short time to help people move into the site. It lasts a week on the profile then goes. Non newbie! lol – jmkjuy Jan 25 '15 at 20:25
  • By the way, welcome to the site! The beginner tag is currently one of the 'tags' which is used to tag topics (i.e. to tag questions) ... it's not used to tag user profiles. The tag is visible in the list of all tags. Each person chooses what tags they use when they create their questions, so the use of tags is haphazard and might be cleaned up sometimes. Currently 13 questions use the beginner tag. – ChrisW Jan 25 '15 at 20:38
  • I already tried to answer that question, here. I don't know what more I could say, to answer that question. – ChrisW Jan 25 '15 at 21:05
  • Sorry mate, I have done the work now and found the right answer if you go back. The most important Precepts are the Ten Precepts. The 227 and 311 are mostly an elaboration and further clarification of the Ten Precepts – jmkjuy Jan 25 '15 at 21:08

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .